Probabilistic record linkage is a method commonly used to determine whether demographic records refer to the same person. Since the late 1990s, various machine learning techniques have been developed that can, under favorable conditions, be used to estimate the conditional probabilities required by the fellegi sunter fs theory. Despite the name, the first stage of probabilistic record linkage is not a statistical issue. Data quality and record linkage techniques thomas n. Sunter, a theory for record linkage, j am stat assoc, 64 1969 11831280. String comparator metrics and enhanced decision rules in. In proceedings of the section on survey research methods, american statistical association 667671. This includes functionalities to conduct a merge of two datasets under the fellegisunter model using the. A number of important record linkage projects have been developed under some variation of the fellegi sunter approach. The fellegi and sunter method is a probabilistic approach to solve record linkage problem based on decision model. A number of important record linkage projects have been developed under some variation of the fellegisunter approach. Howard borden newcombe laid the probabilistic foundations of modern record linkage theory in a 1959 article in science, 2 which were then formalized in 1969 by ivan fellegi and alan sunter who and proved that the probabilistic decision rule they described was optimal when the comparison attributes are conditionally independent. Howard borden newcombe laid the probabilistic foundations of modern record linkage theory in a 1959 article in science, which were then formalized in 1969 by ivan fellegi and alan sunter who proved that the probabilistic.
Our method generalizes the fellegisunter theory for linking records from two data les and its modern implementations. A generalized fellegisunter framework for multiple. Improving record linkage accuracy with hierarchical. Here, we focus on the fellegiholt editimputation model, the littlerubin multipleimputation scheme, and the fellegisunter record linkage model. Developed framework based on concepts like pxvar matches. Sunter 1969, a theory for record linkage, journal of the american statistical association, 64, pp. Comparing record linkage software programs and algorithms. Sunteb dominion bureau of statistics a mathematical model is developed to provide a theoretical framework for a computeroriented solution to the problem of recognizing those records in two files which represent identical persons, objects or events said to be matched. The fellegi sunter method is a probabilistic approach that uses field weights based on log likelihood ratios to determine record similarity. Numerous record linkage programs exist, which differ with respect to cost and methodologic. Record linkage is necessary when joining data sets based on entities that may or may not share a common identifier e. This second report covers implementation issues which are not covered in this report. Record linkage techniques the national academies press.
Citeseerx using the em algorithm for weight computation. Fellegi sunter model of record linkage the fellegi sunter model uses a decisiontheoretic approach establishing the validity of principles first used in practice by newcombe newcombe et al. Fellegi sunter and jaro approach to record linkage method summarythe fellegi and sunter method is a probabilistic approach to solve record linkage problem based on decision model. E using the em algorithm for weight computation in the fellegisunter model of record linkage. The goal of multiple record linkage is to classify the record ktuples coming from kdata les according to the di erent matching patterns. Is there a open source implementation for fellegisunter. Extending the fellegisunter probabilistic record linkage. Fellegisunter model of record linkage the fellegisunter model uses a decisiontheoretic approach establishing the validity of principles first used in practice by newcombe newcombe et al.
Individual patients receive care across many clinical organizations and as a result, patient data are collected from disparate healthcare institutions, pharmacy systems, payers, and public health agencies with different patient identifiers. Our method generalizes the fellegi sunter theory for linking records from two datafiles and its modern implementations. Pdf improved decision rules in the fellegisunter model. Pdf this paper extends techniques for frequencybased matching see e. Computerassisted record linkage goes back as far as the 1950s, when most linkage projects were based on ad hoc heuristic methods. The state of record linkage and current research problems william e. Our method generalizes the fellegisunter theory for linking records from two datafiles and its modern implementations. Winkler, title using the em algorithm for weight computation in the fellegisunter model of record linkage, booktitle proceedings of the section on survey research methods, american statistical association, year 2000, pages 667671. Data cleaning technique for security logs based on fellegi. Fellegisunter and jaro approach to record linkage method.
Bureau of census mainly to match the existing census data with the postenumeration survey 4. This approach dominates in traditional record linkage applications and remains an effective and efficient way to solve the record linkage problem today. For this reason, a couple of other techniques have been developed. Improving record linkage accuracy with hierarchical feature. Using the em algorithm for weight computation in the fellegi. Their pioneering work a theory for record linkage remains the mathematical foundation for many record linkage applications even today. This probability allows to evaluate the quality of the linkage and it has to be taken into account in the following phase of the whole process. Their pioneering work a theory for record linkage 4 is, still today, the mathematical tool for many record linkage applications. Bayesian record linkage and linkage imputation using.
Record linkage rl is the task of finding records in a data set that refer to the same entity. We also varied the weight determination method, using 3 probabilistic approaches fellegisunter, expectationmaximization, epilink, as well as deterministic linkage. Automated linkage of patient records from disparate sources. Nasss current record linkage solution was an early application of the fellegisunter record linkage theory. Newcombe introduced a probabilistic record linkage formula and later fellegi and sunter formalized the theory 1. A checklist for evaluating record linkage software charles day, national agricultural statistics service from the 1950s through the early 1980s, researchers and organizations undertaking a large record linkage project had little choice but to develop their own software.
Statistical research division, methodology and standards directorate, u. This includes functionalities to conduct a merge of two datasets under the fellegi sunter model using the expectationmaximization algorithm. Fellegisunter and jaro approach to record linkage method cros. Sunter pioneered record linkage theory in the late 1950s. Record linkage rl is the task of finding records in a data set that refer to the same entity across different data sources e.
Pdf string comparator metrics and enhanced decision rules. A list of free data matching and record linkage software. Records in data sources are assumed to represent observations of entities taken from a particular population individuals, companies, enterprises, farms, geographic. Fellegi and sunter 1969 at statistics canada was not motivated by health research issues. Improving record linkage performance in the presence of. Extending the fellegisunter probabilistic record linkage method for approximate field comparators. A software tool to prospectively link demographic surveillance and health facility data version 2. Browse other questions tagged java search recordlinkage or ask your own question. Record linkage methods rulesbased enumerate a set of rules for how to decide on matches unwieldy, custom solution needed for each problem probabilistic record linkage fellegi and sunter a theory for record linkage jasa vol. The first part of the book deals with methods and models. Bureau of the census1 abstract this paper provides an overview of methods and systems developed for record linkage. Chapter a checklist for evaluating record linkage software. Numerous record linkage programs exist, which differ with respect to cost and.
The mathematical theory of record linkage work of drs. Record linkage methodology and software have been developed by the u. Apr 22, 20 history formal development of a theory of record linkagestarted with the pioneering work of fellegi and sunter1969. This book offers a practical understanding of issues involved in improving data quality through editing, imputation, and record linkage. The state of record linkage and current research problems. The first practical implementation of probabilistic linkage methodology in the united states was originally designed, programmed, and tested by matt jaro on behalf of the u. Bayesian network classifiersnaive bayes classifier and tan have also been successfully used here. Extending the fellegisunter probabilistic record linkage method for. The standard algorithm for probabilistic record linkage derives from the original work of fellegi and sunter, and its history and development are outlined by winkler. Most of the software packages implement more than one weight determination method.
Title fast probabilistic record linkage with missing data version 0. Implements a fellegi sunter probabilistic record linkage model that allows for missing data and the inclusion of auxiliary information. This is a common scenario when linking census data to coverage measurement surveys for census coverage evaluation, and in general when multiple record systems need to be integrated for posterior analysis. Since the late 1990s, various machine learning techniques have been developed that can, under favorable conditions, be used to estimate the conditional probabilities required by the fellegisunter fs theory. Modern record linkage begins with the pioneering work of newcombe and is especially based on the formal mathematical model of fellegi and sunter.
Our method generalizes the fellegi sunter theory for linking records from two data les and its modern implementations. Glink provides an effective solution to complex recordmatching problems. Matching software, however, that uses threeway weights generally has not performed. The updb may contain links to a marriage certificate and an updated driver license. Weight redistribution, distance imputation, and linkage expansion. The very nature of our work here at statistics canada makes glink an indispensable tool. Most statistical techniques currently used for record linkage are derived from a seminal article by fellegi and sunter in 1969 fellegi, i. This chapter contains a discussion of three major theoretical models supporting modern mdm systems. Healthcare information is increasingly distributed across many sources as we move into an era of electronic health record systems. The fellegisunter method is a probabilistic approach that uses field weights based on log likelihood ratios to determine record similarity.
Here in this approach, a wide range of potential identifiers or keys can be used for record linkage. Jan 11, 2018 rentsch ct, kabudula cw, catlett j et al. To give an overview, we describe the model in terms of ordered pairs in a product space. A generalized fellegisunter framework for multiple record. A mathematical theory of probabilistic linkage was developed by i. The initial idea of record linkage goes back to halbert l. Generalized record linkage system statistics canadas. The theory, developed along the lines of classical hypothesis testing, leads to a linkage rule which is quite similar to. Based on a 1969 jasa paper by ivan fellegi and alan sunter, this theory has. The first part of the book deals with methods and models, focusing on the fellegi holt editimputation model, the littlerubin multipleimputation scheme, and the fellegi sunter record linkage model. By extending the fellegisunter scoring implementations available in the opensource finegrained record linkage fril software system we developed three novel methods to solve the missing data problem in record linkage, which we refer to as. History formal development of a theory of record linkagestarted with the pioneering work of fellegi and sunter1969. To give an overview, we describe the model in terms of ordered pairs in a.
Winkler, title using the em algorithm for weight computation in the fellegi sunter model of record linkage, booktitle proceedings of the section on survey research methods, american statistical association, year 2000, pages 667671. Using the em algorithm for weight computation in the fellegisunter model of record linkage. These administrative data were also being used for statistical purposes. An application of the fellegisunter model of record linkage. If you are attempting to link the two files illustrated in figure 1, you are required to create a file which compares all records in the master file with those in the file of interest. Chapter 3 record linkage big data and social science. Aug 29, 2017 using the em algorithm for weight computation in the fellegi sunter model of record linkage. An introduction to probabilistic record linkage john mac. String comparator metrics and enhanced decision rules in the fellegisunter model of record linkage article pdf available january 1990 with 2,173 reads how we measure reads. In the subsequent generalized recordlinking software developed, there are three main phases in linkage. Match record linkage software package, is also available.
Fellegisunter probabilistic record linkage and its enhanced versions are commonly used methods, which calculate match and nonmatch weights for each pair of records. Dunn in his 1946 article titled record linkage published in the american journal of public health. Probabilistic record linkage is a well established topic in the literature. Formal mathematical model based on generalization of hypothesis testing. Nasss current record linkage solution was an early application of the fellegi sunter record linkage theory. Jan 10, 2017 probabilistic record linkage is a well established topic in the literature. Recordlinkage methodology and software have been developed by the u. The present paper is, the authors hope, an improved version of their own earlier papers on the subject 2, 9, 10. Pdf frequencybased matching in the fellegisunter model of. Sunter dominion bureau of statistics a mathematical model is developed to provide a theoretical framework for a computeroriented solution to the problem of recognizing those records in two files which represent identical persons, objects or events said to be matched. Probabilistic record linkage of deidentified research. Proceedings of the section on survey research methods, american statistical association, vol. Summarizes earlier work and served as the precursor to fellegi and sunter.
The multiple record linkage goal is to classify the record ktuples coming from k datafiles according to the different matching patterns. Browse other questions tagged java search record linkage or ask your own question. Bayesian estimation of bipartite matchings for record linkage. In this section we describe the probabilistic approach to record linkage, also known as the fellegisunter algorithm fellegi and sunter 1969. In the subsequent generalized record linking software developed, there are three main phases in linkage. Sets of ordered pairs q on which the fellegisunter linkage rule is applied. Brief examples are included to show how these techniques work. The software first estimates a bayesian posterior probability that each possible record pair is a true match given all observed agreements and disagreements of field values. Here, we focus on the fellegi holt editimputation model, the littlerubin multipleimputation scheme, and the fellegi sunter record linkage model. Newcombe and kennedy, 1962, and references therein.
314 893 1043 607 589 740 177 1069 898 140 865 562 528 1183 136 1283 1185 1206 1230 196 1378 834 814 567 1254 808 1316 1425 1333 1060 893 245